South Dakota Car Accident Settlement Calculator

What the South Dakota Car Accident Settlement Calculator Does

The calculator is a simple tool that estimates your potential car accident settlement based on a few key numbers and facts:

• Medical bills and future medical costs
• Lost wages from missed work
• Vehicle value and damage severity
• Injury severity (from minor to severe)
• Insurance policy limits
• Fault determination
• Other case-strength factors like police reports, witnesses, and whether you have an attorney

Once you enter your details, it gives you an estimated settlement range — showing the low and high end of what your payout could be.

It’s not a replacement for a lawyer, but it’s a powerful starting point to understand what you might expect before you speak to an attorney.

Understanding South Dakota’s “Slight/Gross” Negligence Rule

Before diving into numbers, it’s important to understand South Dakota’s unique fault rule — the “Slight vs. Gross” negligence standard under SDCL § 20-9-2.

Here’s what that means in plain English:

• If your fault is more than slight, you can’t recover any compensation — even if the other driver was mostly at fault.
• If your fault is slight compared to the other driver’s gross negligence, you can still recover, but your compensation might be reduced.

The calculator assumes that any significant fault bars recovery — meaning if you indicate you were at fault, your estimated settlement will be $0.

This strict rule is one reason South Dakota car accident claims can be complex. Understanding this before negotiating or filing a claim can save you time and stress.

How the Calculator Works Behind the Scenes

The calculator uses a weighted formula to estimate both economic and non-economic damages, then caps the result based on insurance policy limits.

Here’s a simple breakdown:

1. Economic Damages

These are the actual costs you can prove:

• Medical bills (past and future)
• Lost wages
• Other out-of-pocket expenses

2. Non-Economic Damages

These cover pain, suffering, emotional distress, and loss of quality of life.
The calculator estimates these using a multiplier based on your injury severity:

Extra factors like a DUI, commercial vehicle, or having an attorney can slightly increase the multiplier, since they often lead to higher settlements.

3. Property Damage

Property damage is calculated from your vehicle’s pre-accident value and the severity of the damage (from minor to totaled).
Even if your car is fully totaled, the payout is capped at the property damage policy limit — usually $25,000 under South Dakota’s 25/50/25 minimum coverage.

4. Insurance Policy Limits

No matter how high your damages are, your payout can’t exceed the at-fault driver’s insurance coverage.
That’s why entering realistic policy limits is key for accurate results.

Example Calculation

Let’s say:

• Medical bills: $10,000
• Lost wages: $4,000
• Future medical costs: $2,000
• Vehicle value: $12,000 (moderately damaged)
• Injury level: “Moderate” (2.5 multiplier)
• Not at fault
• Policy limits: $25,000 BI / $25,000 PD

The calculator would estimate:

• Economic damages: $16,000
• Non-economic damages: $24,000 (based on multiplier)
• Property damage: ~$9,000
• Capped by insurance limits: Around $25,000 to $33,000 total payout

The final displayed range might look like:
$28,000 – $33,000

That gives you a rough idea of value, though actual settlements depend on legal, medical, and negotiation factors.

Factors That Can Raise or Lower Your Settlement

The calculator also considers case-strength modifiers that can influence how much you might recover:

Increases your payout:

• DUI by the at-fault driver
• Commercial vehicle involvement
• Independent witnesses
• Police report filed
• Legal representation

Decreases your payout:

• Pre-existing injuries
• Long treatment delays
• Partial fault
• Low insurance policy limits

Every case is unique. These factors just help fine-tune your estimate.

What the Calculator Can’t Predict

While the calculator gives a good ballpark estimate, it can’t predict:

• Jury behavior or judge decisions
• How insurance adjusters value pain and suffering
• Settlement negotiations
• Hidden policy limits or umbrella coverage

For serious injuries, talking to an experienced South Dakota car accident attorney can uncover extra compensation sources (like uninsured/underinsured coverage).

Why This Calculator Is South Dakota-Specific

Unlike most states, South Dakota’s negligence law doesn’t follow standard “comparative fault” rules.
That’s why this calculator uses state-specific logic, including:

• The Slight/Gross negligence rule
• The 25/50/25 minimum insurance coverage
• The assumption that fault bars recovery if it’s more than slight

This makes it tailored to real South Dakota cases, not a generic national model.

Calculate Car Accident Settlement Amounts by State with Our Free Calculator