Are you wondering if there are cars that can rival the Jaguar XE‘s perfect blend of style, performance, and luxury? The answer is yes. In fact, several models come close to matching its exceptional features and driving experience. From the sleek Genesis GV70 to the high-performance BMW 340i, these alternatives offer a unique take on the luxury sedan. But which one comes closest to dethroning the XE? Let’s examine the options and discover.
Quick Navigation
Key Takeaways
- The Jaguar XF-S is a similar car to the XE, offering a larger body style and similar performance features.
- The Genesis GV70 is a competitor to the XE, providing a comparable luxury driving experience with advanced safety features.
- The BMW 640i Gran Coupe is a similar car to the XE, offering a powerful engine and premium interior design.
- The Alfa Romeo Giulia is a competitor to the XE, providing a similar blend of performance, style, and luxury features.
- The Audi S3 is a similar car to the XE, offering a high-performance engine and advanced safety features, with better fuel economy.
Design and Features Comparison
As you compare the design and features of the Jaguar XE with its rivals, it’s clear that this luxury sedan stands out from the crowd.
Its classic saloon lines and disciplined proportion give it a more visually well-balanced and elegant design. The XE’s lower bonnet lines, scuttles, and waistlines create a more premium look.
Inside, the XE offers a good-looking, plush interior with Jaguar’s latest Pivi Pro infotainment software and smartphone mirroring as standard.
Its design is undeniably stylish, making it a great choice for those who value aesthetics. The XE’s design is truly good looking, making it a head-turner on the road.
Practicality and Performance Analysis
You’ve fallen for the Jaguar XE’s stunning design, but now it’s time to get down to business and examine its practicality and performance.
While the XE S’s extra power may be hard to use in the UK without getting into trouble, its better bottom end and mid-range would be a practical benefit.
Here’s what you need to know:
- The XE S’s performance is special and hard to match, making it a great combination of comfort and performance.
- The XE S’s ride, refinement, and handling are hard to compromise on, making it a top choice for those prioritizing driving experience.
- The XE’s interior is considered cheap for its price, affecting its overall practicality.
- The XE’s mediocre tires may impact its overall performance and practicality.
Engine and Transmission Options
You’re likely drawn to the Jaguar XE’s performance, particularly the XE S’s turbocharged V6 engine, which packs 335bhp and can sprint from 0-62mph in just 5.1 seconds.
However, it’s essential to examine the engine options of its competitors, such as the BMW 340i’s twin-scroll turbocharged straight-six engine, which produces 322bhp, and the Audi S3’s 2.0-liter turbocharged engine, which puts out 292bhp.
As you evaluate these powertrains, you’ll also want to weigh the transmission options, including the XE’s 8-speed automatic gearbox with paddle shifts and 6-speed manual gearbox.
XE S Powertrain
The Jaguar XE S’s powertrain is a masterclass in performance and refinement, thanks to its turbocharged V6 engine.
This powerhouse produces 335bhp and 332lb-ft of torque, making it a force to be reckoned with on the road.
- Rapid acceleration: 0-62mph in just 5.1 seconds.
- Smooth shifting: Eight-speed ZF automatic transmission for seamless gear changes.
- Dynamic driving: Dynamic Mode firms up the suspension, quickens the steering, and sharpens the throttle response.
- Powerful performance: Turbocharged V6 engine provides exceptional power and agility.
XE Alternatives Compared
While the Jaguar XE S’s powertrain is unquestionably impressive, it’s worth exploring alternative models that offer equally compelling engine and transmission options. If you’re looking for a more flexible mid-range, the BMW 340i’s twin-scroll turbocharged straight-six engine might appeal. Alternatively, the Genesis GV70 and Porsche Macan offer a range of engine options, including turbocharged four-cylinders and twin-turbo V6s. For a powerful and fuel-efficient option, consider the BMW M540d x-drive’s 3.0-liter twin-turbo diesel engine.
| Model | Engine | Power (bhp) |
|---|---|---|
| BMW 340i | Twin-scroll turbocharged straight-six | 322 |
| Genesis GV70 | 2.5-liter turbocharged four-cylinder | 300 |
| Porsche Macan | 3.0-liter twin-turbo V6 | 348 |
| BMW M540d x-drive | 3.0-liter twin-turbo diesel | 326 |
Engine Options Assessed
Beyond raw power, engine character plays a significant role in the driving experience, and the Jaguar XE S’s turbocharged V6 has its unique traits.
When you step on the gas, you’ll notice the XE’s engine feels softer underfoot and doesn’t rev as keenly compared to the BMW 340i.
Here’s how they stack up:
- Engine noise: The BMW’s engine has a quieter engine note, while the XE’s engine is slightly louder.
- Power delivery: The XE’s V6 produces 335bhp, while the BMW’s straight-six engine puts out 322bhp.
- Gearbox: Both cars share the same eight-speed ZF automatic transmission.
- Low-end torque: The BMW’s engine has better low-end torque, making it more flexible in city driving.
Ride, Refinement, and Handling Review
When you get behind the wheel of the Jaguar XE S, you’ll experience exceptional handling, ride, and refinement that sets it apart from its competitors.
You’ll appreciate how it balances comfort and performance, making it a standout in its class.
As you delve into the ride, refinement, and handling of the XE S, you’ll discover why it’s a top choice for those seeking a well-rounded driving experience.
XE S Handling
You’ll be hard-pressed to find a sedan that matches the Jaguar XE S’s exceptional combination of performance, ride, refinement, and handling.
In early tests, it outperformed the 3 series and A4, showcasing its exceptional capabilities.
In terms of handling, the XE S stands out:
- Its better-sounding engine provides a desirable driving experience.
- The extra power, although hard to utilize in the UK, offers practical benefits with its better bottom end and mid-range.
- The XE S is a top choice for those seeking a premium driving experience, rivaling the Giulia in performance and driveability.
- With its exceptional ride, refinement, and handling, the XE S provides an unmatched driving experience.
In the realm of handling, the XE S stands out:
Ride and Refinement
As you step into the Jaguar XE S, its exceptional ride and refinement become immediately apparent. The XE S’s ride is unmatched, offering a perfect blend of comfort and performance. Its refinement is also unparalleled, making it a top choice for those who prioritize a smooth drive.
| Car Model | Ride and Refinement |
|---|---|
| Jaguar XE S | Exceptional ride and refinement, unmatched comfort and performance |
| Alfa Romeo Giulia | Excellent ride and refinement, a worthy alternative to the XE S |
| BMW 3 Series | Good ride, but compromised refinement compared to the XE S |
| Audi A4 | Compromised ride and refinement, lacking in comfort and performance |
The XE S’s superior ride and refinement make it a standout in its class, with its better-sounding engine adding to the overall experience.
Alternatives to Consider
If you’re in the market for a Jaguar XE, you may want to investigate other options that offer similar features and performance.
As you weigh your choices, consider these alternatives:
- XF-S: Offers a similar driving experience with more interior space and a larger boot.
- Genesis GV70: Provides a more premium feel and advanced technology features.
- 640i Gran Coupe: Fits under the price limit and offers a unique blend of style and performance.
- F-Pace 3.0d or V6 petrol: Offers a more practical and spacious alternative to the XE.
These alternatives can provide a comparable or even superior driving experience to the Jaguar XE.
Owner Reviews and Rewards
The Jaguar XE’s impressive performance and features have earned it numerous accolades, and owners rave about their experience behind the wheel.
You’ll find many satisfied owners praising the Jaguar XE’s agility, responsive steering, and smooth transmission. They also appreciate its premium interior, advanced tech features, and impressive fuel economy.
As a result, the Jaguar XE has received several awards, including the 2016 Auto Express Compact Executive Car of the Year and the 2017 What Car? Executive Car of the Year.
With its exceptional performance and luxurious features, it’s no wonder the Jaguar XE is a top choice among car enthusiasts.
Expert Verdict and Comparison
In terms of luxury sedans, you’re spoiled for choice, but how does the Jaguar XE stack up against its closest rivals in respect to performance, design, and overall driving experience?
It compares to the BMW 340i as follows:
- The XE S’s turbocharged V6 engine produces 335bhp, making it much better suited for speed enthusiasts.
- The 340i has a more flexible mid-range and a quieter engine note, but the XE is the more comfortable car.
- The XE’s dramatic design features 20-inch ‘Propellor’ rims and a ‘Riva Hoop’ design feature that encircles the cabin.
- Despite being the more expensive car, the XE is the more fun car to drive and has a more interesting interior.
Fuel Consumption and Emissions
You’ve weighed the Jaguar XE’s performance, design, and driving experience against its rivals, now it’s time to ponder the fuel efficiency and environmental impact of these luxury sedans.
The Jaguar XE S’s fuel consumption is 34.4mpg on the combined cycle, with CO2 emissions of 194g/km.
In comparison, the BMW 340i has a slightly better fuel consumption of 36.7mpg, with lower CO2 emissions of 176g/km.
The Audi S3 leads the pack with a fuel consumption of 39.8mpg and 167g/km CO2 emissions.
If you prioritize fuel efficiency, the BMW M540d x-drive is a strong contender, boasting 44.1mpg and 167g/km CO2 emissions.
Safety Features and Ratings
When you’re looking for a car similar to the Jaguar XE, you’ll want to pay close attention to its impressive safety features and ratings.
The XE boasts a 5-star Euro NCAP rating, thanks to its array of safety technologies, including airbags, crash systems, and advanced assist features.
As you investigate alternative models, you’ll want to compare their safety credentials to the XE’s robust offerings.
Airbag and Crash Systems
The Jaguar XE’s impressive 5-star Euro NCAP rating is a tribute to its robust airbag and crash systems, which provide exceptional protection for drivers and passengers alike.
In terms of airbag protection, you can rest assured that the XE has got you covered.
The standard airbag system includes:
- Dual front airbags
- Front side airbags
- Side curtain airbags
- Optional driver’s knee airbag and seatbelt pretensioners
In respect to overall safety, these features work together to provide a comprehensive layer of protection in the event of a crash, giving you peace of mind on the road.
Safety Assist Technologies
How safe do you feel behind the wheel of a Jaguar XE?
With a range of safety assist technologies, you can drive with confidence.
The Autonomous Emergency Braking system detects pedestrians and vehicles, automatically applying the brakes to prevent or mitigate collisions.
Lane Keep Assist gently steers you back on course if you drift out of your lane.
Adaptive Cruise Control with Queue Assist maintains a safe distance from the vehicle ahead, even bringing you to a complete stop in heavy traffic.
These advanced features, along with the 360-degree parking aid system, provide an added layer of protection on the road.
Euro NCAP Ratings
As you step into the Jaguar XE, you’re backed by a reassuring safety record, with its Euro NCAP ratings serving as a tribute to its robust safety features and rigorous testing.
The XE received a perfect 5-star rating, ensuring you’re well-protected in the event of an accident.
- 5-star rating
- Adult and child occupant protection: The XE scored 92% for adult occupant protection and 82% for child occupant protection, providing peace of mind for you and your passengers.
- Autonomous Emergency Braking: The XE’s AEB system can detect pedestrians, cars, and other obstacles, automatically applying the brakes to avoid or mitigate a collision.
- Strong body structure: The XE’s reinforced passenger compartment and strong body structure helped it achieve a 71% score for safety in the pole impact test.
Ownership Costs and Maintenance
Owning a Jaguar XE can be a costly affair, and you’ll need to factor in more than just the sticker price when calculating the total cost of ownership.
Fuel costs will set you back around $2,000 annually, depending on your driving habits. Insurance premiums are also higher than average, with some policies costing upwards of $1,500 per year.
However, maintenance costs are much less than you’d expect, with routine services averaging around $300. Be sure to budget for these expenses to avoid any financial surprises down the road.
Interior Quality and Comfort
The interior of the Jaguar XE is where its luxury credentials truly shine, with recent model-year revisions elevating the overall quality to surpass its rivals.
You’ll notice the premium feel of the materials, including the piano black plastic trim, which adds a touch of sophistication to the cabin.
Here’s what you can expect:
- Soft-touch materials and premium upholstery that envelop you in comfort.
- A spacious and airy feel, thanks to the XE’s generous head and leg room.
- A sleek, modern design that exudes luxury and refinement.
- Ample storage compartments and clever touches, like the sliding armrest, to keep you organized on the go.
Technology and Infotainment Systems
How do you stay connected and entertained on the go?
The Jaguar XE’s infotainment system falls short, with some owners finding it outdated and less user-friendly compared to its rivals.
You can opt for the InControl Pro system to improve the experience, but it still lags behind German luxury car brands.
For instance, the BMW 340i’s iDrive system is easy to use and features a satisfying control wheel.
The Audi S3 also offers more advanced technology, including a modern and intuitive infotainment system.
If staying connected is important to you, you may want to weigh these alternatives.
Driving Experience and Road Holding
Steering the Jaguar XE can be a trying experience, as it’s overly sensitive to wind, making it difficult for you to maintain a constant course, especially when cruising at high speeds.
This can be unsettling, to say the least.
When you switch to dynamic mode, you expect a more engaging drive, but the XE’s road holding is compromised, making it feel unglued to the ground.
Here’s what you can expect:
- A constant battle to keep the car on course, especially on windy days.
- A sense of unease when driving at high speeds due to the car’s sensitivity to wind.
- A less-than-ideal driving experience, particularly when compared to compact GTI-type cars.
- A car that feels less planted on the road, which can be unsettling for even the most experienced drivers.
Other Options to Explore
Considering the Jaguar XE’s shortcomings, you might want to examine other options that better fit your needs. If you’re looking for a more spacious interior, the XF-S or 640i Gran Coupe could be the way to go. For a more practical SUV alternative, the F-Pace 3.0d or V6 petrol is worth exploring. If luxury and modern features are your priority, the Genesis GV70 is a great option. And if you’re after a fun-to-drive compact car, the Mini Clubman JCW is a great alternative.
| Model | Key Feature | Benefit |
|---|---|---|
| XF-S | Spacious interior | More room for passengers |
| Genesis GV70 | Modern features | Better tech and luxury |
| Mini Clubman JCW | Fun-to-drive | More engaging driving experience |
Conclusion
You’ve narrowed down your search to cars similar to the Jaguar XE, and now you’re spoiled for choice. Like a master chef with a rich bouquet of ingredients, you can mix and match features to create your perfect blend. From the Genesis GV70’s sleek design to the BMW 340i’s refined engine, each alternative offers a unique flavor. Take your time, taste-test each option, and savor the ride that suits your style.
