You’re considering purchasing a BMW M4, but want to know which years to focus on or avoid. The first generation, spanning 2014 to 2020, had some issues, particularly with the 2015 model.
Meanwhile, the second generation, starting in 2021, has shown promise in reliability. As you look for a reliable option, models from 2016 and 2017 are often highlighted for their balance of performance and dependability. But what makes these years stand out?
Quick Navigation
Key Takeaways
- Best Years: 2016 and 2017 BMW M4 models are considered reliable and safe to purchase, with fewer reported issues compared to other model years.
- Worst Years: Avoid 2015, 2019, 2020, and 2021 BMW M4 models due to problems such as oil leaks, cracked seats, and valve cover gasket issues.
- Reliability Factors: Regular maintenance is crucial for the M4’s longevity; monitor oil levels and address wear and tear promptly to maintain value.
- Latest Models: 2025 BMW M4 features advanced driver-assistance systems, improved interiors, and robust twin-turbo engines, making it a strong modern choice.
- High-Mileage & Track Use: Higher mileage models or those with track histories may have more wear and potential reliability concerns, impacting long-term dependability.
BMW M4 Overview
The BMW M4 is a high-performance variant of the BMW 4 Series, offering a dynamic driving experience combined with the luxurious features of a contemporary vehicle.
As you delve into the BMW M4, you’ll find it packs a twin-turbocharged 3.0-liter inline-six engine, providing robust power and speed.
The M4 is known for its sporty driving dynamics, courtesy of its motorsport-derived features like the Active M Differential and adaptive M Suspension.
Inside, it shares the 4 Series’ architecture but with distinctive M Division touches, such as sport seats and M-specific displays.
First Generation M4 (2014-2020)
If you’re researching the First Generation BMW M4 (2014–2020), you’ll find certain years stand out for recurring problems,
with the 2015 model especially prone to wheel/hub and brake issues and the 2020 facing concerns like fuel leaks and airbag malfunctions.
Later model years, particularly after BMW addressed early reliability concerns, generally offer improved dependability and are more frequently recommended.
Throughout this generation, you can expect the S55 turbocharged engine, responsive handling, and a choice between manual and dual-clutch transmissions as key performance highlights.
Years With Common Issues
When considering the first-generation BMW M4 (2014-2020), there are specific years and issues you should be aware of.
The 2015 model is particularly problematic, with wheel and hub issues, brake troubles, and potential power steering problems.
Additionally, engine issues such as oil leaks from the valve cover gasket and cooling system faults are common across this generation.
These problems can significantly impact the driving experience and maintenance costs.
Always inspect these components thoroughly if you’re considering purchasing a used model from this period.
Recommended Model Years
You’re looking for the best model years of the first-generation BMW M4 (2014-2020).
The 2014 BMW M4 is a good option, offering a twin-turbo engine with 425 horsepower.
The 2016 BMW M4 stands out with its powerful engine and improved performance features.
The 2017 BMW M4 is known for its high-performance capabilities and sport-tuned suspension.
Finally, the 2018 BMW M4 updated features, such as new headlights and revised tuning, making it a great choice for those seeking modern capabilities.
These model years provide a balance of performance and reliability.
Key Performance Features
The first-generation BMW M4, produced from 2014 to 2020, showcased impressive performance capabilities thanks to its twin-turbo 3.0-liter inline-six engine. You get a choice between a six-speed manual or a quicker seven-speed dual-clutch automatic, ensuring you can tailor the driving experience to your style. Motorsport-inspired features like lightweight suspension, body panels, and the Active M Differential let you enjoy improved traction and nimble handling. The adaptive M Suspension, with Comfort, Sport, and Sport+ modes, lets you fine-tune your ride for comfort or maximum performance on demand.
| Feature | Description |
|---|---|
| Engine | Twin-turbo 3.0L inline-six, 425 hp, 406 lb-ft torque |
| Transmission | 6-speed manual / 7-speed dual-clutch automatic |
| Drivetrain Technology | Active M Differential (electronically controlled) |
| Suspension | Adaptive M Suspension (Comfort, Sport, Sport+) |
Second Generation M4 (2021-present)
As you delve into the second-generation M4, you’ll find it offers robust engine performance with its twin-turbocharged 3.0-liter inline-six, producing 425 horsepower.
Inside, the M4 boasts a high-grade interior with M-specific features like sport seats and a driver display.
In terms of reliability, you should be aware of issues like the seat belt warning chime and passenger seatbelt faults in some 2021 models, as well as the potential for noises in the cockpit on bumpy roads.
Engine and Performance
Powering the second-generation M4 is a potent twin-turbocharged 3.0-liter inline-six engine, available in both two-door coupe and convertible body styles.
You’ll get 473 horsepower and 406 lb-ft of torque, allowing for swift acceleration, especially with the optional all-wheel-drive system.
The engine is paired with an 8-speed automatic transmission, while rear-wheel-drive models offer a 6-speed manual option.
The Active M Differential electronically controls power delivery for improved grip and handling.
Interior and Technology
You’re stepping inside the second-generation BMW M4, and you’ll find an interior that’s just as impressive as its performance.
The M4 features a high-grade interior with M-specific designs, including a driver display and gear lever.
A 3-spoke leather-wrapped steering wheel provides controls for various functions.
Standard equipment includes climate control and a Harman Kardon audio system.
The M4 shares its basic architecture with the 4 Series but adds sport seats and other M Division details.
Technology includes a 12.3-inch touchscreen and Apple CarPlay integration.
Reliability and Issues
The second-generation BMW M4 (2021-present) enjoys a strong reputation for reliability, with no major recalls or common mechanical problems reported since its debut.
Its reliability is attributed to advanced technology and rigorous testing.
- No major recalls or common issues reported.
- Advanced technology improves performance and durability.
- Improved manufacturing processes reduce defects.
- Rigorous testing guarantees quality standards are met.
- It avoids common issues from earlier models.
Performance and Handling
Driving an M4 is an exhilarating experience, thanks to its motorsport-derived features that boost its performance and handling.
The adaptive M Suspension offers Comfort, Sport, and Sport+ modes, letting you tailor ride quality and responsiveness—from relaxed cruising to aggressive track driving.
Its electronically controlled Active M Differential dynamically distributes power between the rear wheels, enhancing traction and cornering precision.
The optional M carbon package sheds weight with carbon fiber parts, improving agility and control.
Whether you prioritize comfort or sporty dynamics, the M4’s setup guarantees it stands out as a true performance car, blending daily usability with racetrack capability.
Interior and Features
As you delve into the interior of the BMW M4, you’ll notice that seating comfort levels are elevated by sport seats designed specifically by the M Division.
The infotainment and connectivity features have evolved with updates like the new iDrive system introduced in the 2018 LCI update, offering a more intuitive interface.
You’ll also appreciate the quality of interior materials, with options ranging from standard trim to bespoke details in special-edition models like the M4 CS.
Seating Comfort Levels
When you step into the BMW M4, you’ll find a sophisticated interior that combines sportiness with comfort.
The M4’s sport seats—including optional M carbon buckets—offer impressive lateral support and are praised for their comfort, even on long journeys, though some may find the bolstering restrictive.
The convertible adds the air scarf for extra coziness when driving topless.
Rear seats accommodate real adults, though taller passengers may feel cramped.
The overall experience balances daily usability with a performance focus.
- Sporty Design: Standard and optional seats are built for spirited driving.
- Supportive: Bolstering keeps you firmly in place during hard cornering.
- Long-Distance Comfort: Surprisingly comfortable for extended trips.
- Air Scarf: Unique to convertibles, it provides warmth in cooler weather.
- Rear Seats Practicality: Foldable and usable, but headroom is limited for tall passengers.
Infotainment and Connectivity
BMW M4’s infotainment and connectivity features center on the standard iDrive system, bringing intuitive controls and crisp graphics to the driver’s fingertips.
Over the years, iDrive has evolved, with newer models—like the 2023 and beyond—boasting larger screens, more advanced features, and a sleeker interface as standard.
Optional upgrades include a head-up display and Harman Kardon audio. Apple CarPlay smartphone integration is supported, but Android Auto remains unavailable.
The interior’s M-specific digital display and premium materials—leather, aluminum, and carbon fiber—complement the system, creating a luxurious, sport-focused cockpit.
Interior Material Quality
How does the BMW M4 interior stand out in terms of material quality and features?
You’ll notice premium leather, aluminum accents, and carbon fiber trim—materials that raise the cabin and reflect the car’s high-performance DNA.
The M4’s commitment to quality is clear in every detail, from the stitched upholstery to the supportive sport seats.
Long-term owners report that these materials, even after years, resist wear and maintain their upscale look.
The dashboard and controls are laid out for the driver, and ambient lighting adds a personalized touch.
- Premium leather seats with high-grade stitched upholstery
- Carbon fiber trim for a sporty, sophisticated look
- Aluminum accents and high-quality surfaces throughout
- Ambient lighting for customizable cabin mood
- Durable materials that resist wear and maintain appearance
Reliability and Maintenance Costs
Several model years of the BMW M4 show distinct reliability and maintenance traits that affect ownership costs.
Years to avoid include 2015, 2019, 2020, and 2021, due to issues like oil leaks and cracked seats.
However, reliability is generally good when you avoid high-mileage models or track use.
Regular maintenance is key to maintaining performance and value.
You’ll want to monitor oil levels since BMWs can burn oil.
Regular checks and a history of proper maintenance can keep your M4 running smoothly and maintain its value over time.
Common Problems With the M4
Beyond reliability ratings and routine upkeep, certain difficulties have surfaced as all too familiar for M4 owners over the years.
The M4 faces several notable issues:
- Crank Hub Issue: Serious, more common in tuned cars and DCT models.
- Valve cover and gasket leaks.
- Oil pan gasket leaks.
- Turbocharger inlet seal issues.
- Oil burning, requiring frequent topping up.
DCT models are more prone to some of these issues, while garage storage can delay gasket replacements.
M4 Model Years to Avoid
When you’re researching M4 model years to avoid, major mechanical faults are a key red flag, with early production years often showing more issues in areas like engine gaskets and oil leaks.
Recall frequency is another concern; models from 2014 and 2015, for example, faced recalls related to seatbelts and power steering, signaling potentially higher risk for owners.
Build quality can also flag certain years, as first-year cars may have unresolved problems that later models address through updates and revisions.
Major Mechanical Faults
If you’re considering purchasing a BMW M4, it’s crucial to be aware of the model years that are prone to major mechanical faults.
Many owners and experts point to specific recurring issues, especially in earlier models.
- Rod Bearing Wear: Can cause engine knock or catastrophic failure; prevalent in 2015 models.
- Crank Hub Issues: Weak factory design leading to potential engine damage, especially in modified cars.
- Turbocharger Failures: Overheating, unusual noises, and performance dips.
- Dual-Clutch Transmission (DCT) Problems: Rough shifting, delays, and slippage.
- Oil and Coolant Leaks: Cracks in rocker covers and gasket failures reported in multiple years.
Recall Frequency Issues
As you consider purchasing a BMW M4, understanding which model years have higher recall frequencies can help you make a more informed decision. Some model years are more prone to recalls due to mechanical faults.
| Model Year | Recall Issue | Affected Vehicles |
|---|---|---|
| 2015-2016 | Driveshaft | M3, M4 Coupe, Convertible |
| 2016-2017 | Driveshaft Failure | M3, M4 Coupe, Convertible |
| 2020-2021 | Fuel Injector | M2 Coupe, M4 Coupe |
Build Quality Concerns
Purchasing a BMW M4 requires careful consideration of its build quality, particularly in identifying model years that may have more issues.
Build quality concerns often arise in early production years and specific recalls affecting safety and drivability.
Specifically, the 2015-2016 models faced rear subframe bolt looseness and driveshaft lubrication problems.
The 2016-2017 M4s had driveshaft flange separation risks, while 2019-2020 versions were recalled for faulty fuel injectors potentially causing fuel leaks.
Watch for these build quality concerns in these model years:
- Early production glitches (2015-2016)
- Rear subframe bolt issues
- Driveshaft slip joint lubrication failures
- Driveshaft flange separation
- Faulty fuel injectors in 2019-2020
These factors help you avoid problematic M4 builds.
Recommended M4 Model Years
Among the recommended BMW M4 model years, the 2016 and 2017 versions stand out for their balance of performance and reliability, making them solid choices. The 2016 M4 Competition introduced the Competition Package, adding 14 hp, Style 666 wheels, and revised M Mode tuning. The 2017 model carried these upgrades forward without major changes but remained highly dependable. While the 2015 model is generally reliable, it is often advised to approach it cautiously due to early-production issues. The 2021 M4, part of the second generation, offers advanced tech and all-wheel drive options.
| Model Year | Key Features | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| 2015 | Reliable base model | Early issues; buy carefully |
| 2016 | Competition Package added | Power, wheels, tuning |
| 2017 | Same as 2016 | Solid reliability |
| 2021 | Second-gen, twin-turbo I6 | AWD option, upgraded tech |
Special Editions and Variants
- M4 GTS: Limited to 300 units in the US, this track-focused model boasts 493 horsepower and unique chassis tweaks.
- M4 CS: Priced around $70,000, with 454 horsepower, less aggressive styling, and bespoke trim.
- M4 Edition ///M Heritage Coupe: Features M4 Competition Package, exclusive colors, and unique interior details.
- M4 Competition Package: Includes 19-inch wheels, adaptive suspension, and a sport exhaust, adding $5,500 to the price.
- M4 DTM Champion Edition & 30 Jahre Edition: Commemorative models with special colors and limited production.
M4 Pricing and Value
When considering the pricing and value of the BMW M4, you’ll find that early high-mileage models can be purchased for around $25,000, while lower-mileage cars typically cost about $31,000.
Lower-mileage M4s are often priced between $45,000 and $65,000.
The M4 GTS, being more exclusive, commands higher prices of about $70,000 or more, depending on condition and maintenance.
Regular maintenance is key to maintaining both performance and value of the BMW M4.
BMW M4 Generations Compared
How do the different generations of the BMW M4 stack up?
The first-generation M4 (2014-2020) offered a coupe or convertible with distinctive styling.
The second generation, introduced in 2021, features a twin-turbo engine and optional all-wheel drive.
- Powertrain: Twin-turbo engines in newer models.
- Body Styles: Coupe and convertible options in both generations.
- Interior: High-grade interiors in newer models.
- Performance Options: M carbon packages and all-wheel drive.
- Production Periods: First generation from 2014 to 2020, second from 2021 onwards.
Safety Features and Recalls
The BMW M4’s evolution across generations hasn’t only refined performance and design but also significantly improved safety features.
You’ll find standard blind-spot monitoring, rear cross-traffic alert, lane-departure warning, and lane-keeping assist in the latest models.
The 2025 version includes even more advanced driver-assistance systems.
In terms of recalls, always verify the latest data to guarantee your vehicle is up-to-date.
BMW generally provides comprehensive warranty coverage, including a limited and powertrain warranty, which helps mitigate any potential issues.
Regular maintenance is key to avoiding recall-related problems.
Upgrades and Customization Options
Customization options for the BMW M4 are extensive, allowing you to personalize your vehicle’s appearance and performance.
You can opt for the Competition Package, which adds $5,500 and boosts power to 444 horsepower.
The M4 also offers paint options via BMW Individual.
- Competition Package: Adds power and M Adaptive Suspension.
- M4 GTS: Features carbon fiber hood and carbon-ceramic brakes.
- BMW Individual Paint: Includes Fashion Gray, Austin Yellow Metallic.
- M4 CS: Offers 454 horsepower with a less aggressive design.
- Edition ///M Heritage Coupe: Bespoke trim details.
Buying a Used BMW M4
Buying a used BMW M4 demands careful consideration of model years and common issues to avoid costly repairs.
The years to avoid are 2015, 2019, 2020, and 2021 due to problems like oil leaks and valve cover gasket issues.
However, models from 2016 and 2017 are considered reliable and safe to purchase.
Prices for a used BMW M4 vary widely, from about $24,000 to $150,000, depending on factors like condition and mileage.
Regular maintenance is vital to maintaining performance and value.
When looking at performance cars, make sure to check out our guides on models like the BMW 8 Series, BMW I3, BMW X7 and BMW I4. Knowing which model years to target and which to avoid is crucial. Our expert reviews break down these models, providing insights into the years that are celebrated for their engineering excellence and driving satisfaction, as well as those that are best to avoid due to potential issues.
